If you’re on the search for the best manual breast pump to fit your lifestyle, you may find yourself comparing the Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump with the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump. Both of these breast pumps cost roughly $30.00, and have several similar features. For instance, both the Medela Harmony and the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pumps are lightweight, portable, and quiet. Both offer ergonomic handles for comfort as well as one-handed operation. This means that you don’t have to hold the bottle with one hand while you pump with the other, they’re extremely stable and easy to use. Both the Medela Harmony and the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump come with two bottles and two lids, as well as bottle stands. Both manual breast pumps have minimal parts for cleanup and are dishwasher safe. Both also offer 24 mm breast shields, which is the standard size. The Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump offers a ComfortSeal cushion breast shield, while the Medela Harmony offers a SoftFit breast shield. Both are designed with the same purpose, a secure comfortable fit.
Now for the differences. The Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump offers 2 phase expression technology, the stimulation phase and the expression phase. The handle itself has two different pumping actions. If you look at the picture of the Medela Harmony you’ll see that there are actually two parts to the handle, one small lever in front, and the longer lever in back. To start the stimulation phase you use the smaller lever. This will mimic a baby’s quick natural sucking rhythm. Once the stimulation phase is completed, you can use the longer part of the handle in the back to continue on with the expression phase, which is a longer, deeper sucking rhythm. The Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump does not offer a double action handle, but you can still mimic these two expression phases by hand. In addition, the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump comes with an extra valve, as well as a flange cleaning brush.
As for reviews, both of these manual breast pumps did quite well. The Medela Harmony Manual Breast Pump had more reviews, with 161 out of 206 reviewers rating it 4 to 5 stars, with a max of 5. That’s about a 78% customer satisfaction rating. Now the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump had less reviews, but it also had a higher customer satisfaction rating. With 87 out of 98 reviewers rating it 4 to 5 stars, that’s an 89% customer satisfaction rating. Both received basically the same complaints, number one being that it takes a while to empty your breasts. This is normal for manual breast pumps, especially if you’re comparing them to electric breast pumps. The only other complaints were that the manual operation can get quite tiresome, and they both will lose suction if incorrectly assembled. Yet again, these complaints are pretty normal for manual breast pumps. There were a couple reviewers that complained about a leaking problem with the Medela Harmony, but that was usually only when it got tipped over.
In conclusion, both the Medela Harmony and the Lansinoh Manual Breast Pumps are excellent choices. However, if you are having trouble establishing your milk supply, or struggling with a low milk supply, I would NOT suggest using a manual breast pump. The reason for this is that if you are trying to build your supply you will need to empty your breasts completely, and a manual breast pump just does not have the strength for that. I would suggest checking out the double electric breast pumps, or even a single electric breast pump for that.
For more information on either manual breast pump listed above, check out the full in-depth reviews listed below.